{"slug":"butler-oh","label":"Butler, OH","version":"1.0","period":"2026-Q4","as_of":"2026-10-29T21:08:02Z","url":"https://joyproject.com/cities/butler-oh/score","citation":"Joy Project City Score v1.0, Butler, OH, 2026-Q4, joyproject.com/cities/butler-oh/score","methodology_url":"https://joyproject.com/methodology/v1.0","city_score":48,"condition":48,"movement":null,"movement_only":false,"status":{"key":"liberty","label":"Liberty","since":"2026-10-29","at_risk":false,"next":{"key":"revival","gaps":[{"key":"overall","label":"City Pulse","current":0.0,"needed":40.0,"detail":"City Pulse 0 → 40"},{"key":"pillar:prayer","label":"Prayer","current":0.0,"needed":45.0,"detail":"Prayer 0 → 45"},{"key":"pillar:discipleship","label":"Discipleship","current":0.0,"needed":45.0,"detail":"Discipleship 0 → 45"},{"key":"pillar:unity","label":"Unity","current":0.0,"needed":45.0,"detail":"Unity 0 → 45"}]},"history":[{"key":"liberty","entered_on":"2026-10-29","exited_on":null}]},"indexes":[{"key":"burden","label":"What Butler is up against","score":40,"percentile":62.2,"trend":18.5,"coverage":0.5,"headline":"Better than 62% of cities, up 19 points","indicators":[{"key":"violent_crime_rate","label":"Violent crime","value":269.4,"unit":"offences per 100,000","percentile":51.9,"trend":-4.6,"period":"2025","geo_type":"state","geo_label":"Ohio","suppressed":false,"reason":null,"verified_in_joy":false,"source":{"key":"fbi_crime","name":"FBI Crime Data Explorer","url":"https://api.usa.gov/crime/fbi/cde","licence":"public domain","citation":"FBI Crime Data Explorer (reporting gaps noted)"},"source_url":"https://api.usa.gov/crime/fbi/cde/summarized/state/OH/violent-crime?from=01-2022\u0026to=12-2025"},{"key":"property_crime_rate","label":"Property crime","value":1376.19,"unit":"offences per 100,000","percentile":59.4,"trend":10.3,"period":"2025","geo_type":"state","geo_label":"Ohio","suppressed":false,"reason":null,"verified_in_joy":false,"source":{"key":"fbi_crime","name":"FBI Crime Data Explorer","url":"https://api.usa.gov/crime/fbi/cde","licence":"public domain","citation":"FBI Crime Data Explorer (reporting gaps noted)"},"source_url":"https://api.usa.gov/crime/fbi/cde/summarized/state/OH/property-crime?from=01-2022\u0026to=12-2025"},{"key":"sti_rate","label":"Sexually transmitted infections","value":null,"unit":"chlamydia, gonorrhea and syphilis cases per 100,000","percentile":null,"trend":null,"period":null,"geo_type":null,"geo_label":null,"suppressed":false,"reason":"no data","verified_in_joy":false,"source":{"key":"cdc_atlasplus","name":"CDC NCHHSTP AtlasPlus","url":"https://www.cdc.gov/nchhstp/atlas/","licence":"public domain","citation":"CDC, NCHHSTP AtlasPlus"},"source_url":null},{"key":"overdose_death_rate","label":"Drug overdose deaths","value":15.21,"unit":"deaths per 100,000","percentile":70.3,"trend":54.9,"period":"2025","geo_type":"county","geo_label":"Richland County, OH","suppressed":false,"reason":null,"verified_in_joy":false,"source":{"key":"cdc_vsrr_overdoses","name":"CDC NCHS, provisional county drug overdose deaths (VSRR)","url":"https://data.cdc.gov/resource/gb4e-yj24.json","licence":"public domain (counts under 10 suppressed)","citation":"CDC National Center for Health Statistics, Vital Statistics Rapid Release: provisional county-level drug overdose death counts"},"source_url":"https://data.cdc.gov/resource/gb4e-yj24.json?month=12\u0026$limit=50000\u0026$select=year,fips,countyname,st_abbrev,provisional_drug_overdose,footnote,percentage_of_records_pending"},{"key":"outlets_adult","label":"Adult entertainment outlets","value":null,"unit":"mapped places per 100,000","percentile":null,"trend":null,"period":null,"geo_type":null,"geo_label":null,"suppressed":false,"reason":"no data","verified_in_joy":false,"source":{"key":"osm_outlets","name":"OpenStreetMap outlet counts (Metro pulse, metro_reformation_stats)","url":"https://www.openstreetmap.org","licence":"ODbL (\"© OpenStreetMap contributors\" on every page that shows a count)","citation":"© OpenStreetMap contributors"},"source_url":null},{"key":"outlets_gambling","label":"Gambling outlets","value":null,"unit":"mapped places per 100,000","percentile":null,"trend":null,"period":null,"geo_type":null,"geo_label":null,"suppressed":false,"reason":"no data","verified_in_joy":false,"source":{"key":"osm_outlets","name":"OpenStreetMap outlet counts (Metro pulse, metro_reformation_stats)","url":"https://www.openstreetmap.org","licence":"ODbL (\"© OpenStreetMap contributors\" on every page that shows a count)","citation":"© OpenStreetMap contributors"},"source_url":null},{"key":"outlets_cannabis","label":"Cannabis outlets","value":null,"unit":"mapped places per 100,000","percentile":null,"trend":null,"period":null,"geo_type":null,"geo_label":null,"suppressed":false,"reason":"no data","verified_in_joy":false,"source":{"key":"osm_outlets","name":"OpenStreetMap outlet counts (Metro pulse, metro_reformation_stats)","url":"https://www.openstreetmap.org","licence":"ODbL (\"© OpenStreetMap contributors\" on every page that shows a count)","citation":"© OpenStreetMap contributors"},"source_url":null},{"key":"outlets_liquor","label":"Liquor outlets and bars","value":null,"unit":"mapped places per 100,000","percentile":null,"trend":null,"period":null,"geo_type":null,"geo_label":null,"suppressed":false,"reason":"no data","verified_in_joy":false,"source":{"key":"osm_outlets","name":"OpenStreetMap outlet counts (Metro pulse, metro_reformation_stats)","url":"https://www.openstreetmap.org","licence":"ODbL (\"© OpenStreetMap contributors\" on every page that shows a count)","citation":"© OpenStreetMap contributors"},"source_url":null},{"key":"outlets_predatory_lending","label":"Predatory lenders","value":null,"unit":"mapped places per 100,000","percentile":null,"trend":null,"period":null,"geo_type":null,"geo_label":null,"suppressed":false,"reason":"no data","verified_in_joy":false,"source":{"key":"osm_outlets","name":"OpenStreetMap outlet counts (Metro pulse, metro_reformation_stats)","url":"https://www.openstreetmap.org","licence":"ODbL (\"© OpenStreetMap contributors\" on every page that shows a count)","citation":"© OpenStreetMap contributors"},"source_url":null},{"key":"abortion_facilities_per_100k","label":"Abortion facilities (mapped)","value":null,"unit":"mapped facilities per 100,000 (a floor)","percentile":null,"trend":null,"period":null,"geo_type":null,"geo_label":null,"suppressed":false,"reason":"no data","verified_in_joy":false,"source":{"key":"osm_outlets","name":"OpenStreetMap outlet counts (Metro pulse, metro_reformation_stats)","url":"https://www.openstreetmap.org","licence":"ODbL (\"© OpenStreetMap contributors\" on every page that shows a count)","citation":"© OpenStreetMap contributors"},"source_url":null}]},{"key":"grace","label":"Where grace is growing","score":25,"percentile":34.2,"trend":0.0,"coverage":1.0,"headline":"Better than 34% of cities","indicators":[{"key":"church_adherents_share","label":"Church adherents","value":439.51,"unit":"adherents per 1,000 residents","percentile":40.6,"trend":null,"period":"2020","geo_type":"county","geo_label":"Richland County, OH","suppressed":false,"reason":null,"verified_in_joy":false,"source":{"key":"religion_census","name":"2020 U.S. Religion Census","url":"https://usreligioncensus.org/node/1639","licence":"free with citation","citation":"2020 U.S. Religion Census, Association of Statisticians of American Religious Bodies"},"source_url":"https://www.usreligioncensus.org/sites/default/files/2023-06/2020_USRC_Summaries.xlsx"},{"key":"congregations_per_10k","label":"Congregations","value":16.33,"unit":"congregations per 10,000 residents","percentile":34.2,"trend":null,"period":"2020","geo_type":"county","geo_label":"Richland County, OH","suppressed":false,"reason":null,"verified_in_joy":false,"source":{"key":"religion_census","name":"2020 U.S. Religion Census","url":"https://usreligioncensus.org/node/1639","licence":"free with citation","citation":"2020 U.S. Religion Census, Association of Statisticians of American Religious Bodies"},"source_url":"https://www.usreligioncensus.org/sites/default/files/2023-06/2020_USRC_Summaries.xlsx"},{"key":"charitable_giving_share","label":"Charitable giving","value":0.66,"unit":"itemized charitable deductions as % of adjusted gross income","percentile":41.7,"trend":null,"period":"2023","geo_type":"county","geo_label":"Richland County, OH","suppressed":false,"reason":null,"verified_in_joy":false,"source":{"key":"irs_soi","name":"IRS Statistics of Income, county data","url":"https://www.irs.gov/statistics/soi-tax-stats-county-data","licence":"public domain","citation":"IRS Statistics of Income, individual income tax county data"},"source_url":"https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-soi/23incyallagi.csv"},{"key":"local_giving_usd","label":"Given to local needs in Joy","value":0.0,"unit":"dollars per 100,000 residents, trailing 12 months","percentile":0.0,"trend":0.0,"period":"2026-09","geo_type":"county","geo_label":"39139 (1 city summed)","suppressed":false,"reason":null,"verified_in_joy":true,"source":{"key":"ledger","name":"Verified in Joy (the impact ledger)","url":"https://joyproject.com","licence":"Joy Project","citation":"Joy Project impact ledger"},"source_url":null},{"key":"needs_met","label":"Needs met in Joy","value":0.0,"unit":"per 100,000 residents, trailing 12 months","percentile":0.0,"trend":0.0,"period":"2026-09","geo_type":"county","geo_label":"39139 (1 city summed)","suppressed":false,"reason":null,"verified_in_joy":true,"source":{"key":"ledger","name":"Verified in Joy (the impact ledger)","url":"https://joyproject.com","licence":"Joy Project","citation":"Joy Project impact ledger"},"source_url":null},{"key":"volunteers_mobilized","label":"Volunteers mobilized in Joy","value":0.0,"unit":"per 100,000 residents, trailing 12 months","percentile":0.0,"trend":0.0,"period":"2026-09","geo_type":"county","geo_label":"39139 (1 city summed)","suppressed":false,"reason":null,"verified_in_joy":true,"source":{"key":"ledger","name":"Verified in Joy (the impact ledger)","url":"https://joyproject.com","licence":"Joy Project","citation":"Joy Project impact ledger"},"source_url":null},{"key":"believers","label":"New believers in Joy","value":0.0,"unit":"per 100,000 residents, trailing 12 months","percentile":0.0,"trend":0.0,"period":"2026-09","geo_type":"county","geo_label":"39139 (1 city summed)","suppressed":false,"reason":null,"verified_in_joy":true,"source":{"key":"ledger","name":"Verified in Joy (the impact ledger)","url":"https://joyproject.com","licence":"Joy Project","citation":"Joy Project impact ledger"},"source_url":null},{"key":"app_searches_for_church","label":"Searches for a church in Joy","value":0.0,"unit":"per 100,000 residents, trailing 12 months","percentile":0.0,"trend":0.0,"period":"2026-09","geo_type":"county","geo_label":"39139 (1 city summed)","suppressed":false,"reason":null,"verified_in_joy":true,"source":{"key":"ledger","name":"Verified in Joy (the impact ledger)","url":"https://joyproject.com","licence":"Joy Project","citation":"Joy Project impact ledger"},"source_url":null},{"key":"foster_adoption_ministry_families","label":"Foster and adoptive families in the churches","value":0.0,"unit":"per 100,000 residents","percentile":0.0,"trend":null,"period":"2026-10","geo_type":"county","geo_label":"39139 (1 city summed)","suppressed":false,"reason":null,"verified_in_joy":true,"source":{"key":"church_entries","name":"Church workspace entries (church-attested)","url":"https://joyproject.com","licence":"Joy Project","citation":"JoyProject church workspace, church-attested"},"source_url":null}]},{"key":"family","label":"Marriage \u0026 family","score":39,"percentile":35.0,"trend":-3.8,"coverage":0.95,"headline":"Better than 35% of cities, down 4 points","indicators":[{"key":"children_with_married_parents_share","label":"Children with married parents","value":70.06,"unit":"% of own children under 18 in married-couple families","percentile":46.6,"trend":0.0,"period":"2020-2024","geo_type":"county","geo_label":"Richland County, OH","suppressed":false,"reason":null,"verified_in_joy":false,"source":{"key":"census_acs","name":"Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-year","url":"https://api.census.gov/data","licence":"public domain","citation":"U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-Year Estimates"},"source_url":"https://api.census.gov/data/2024/acs/acs5?get=NAME,B12501_005E,B12501_005M,B12501_010E,B12501_010M,B12001_001E,B12001_001M\u0026for=county:*"},{"key":"adults_25_44_married_share","label":"Adults 25-44 married","value":45.2,"unit":"% of people 25-44 married, spouse present","percentile":31.4,"trend":0.0,"period":"2020-2024","geo_type":"county","geo_label":"Richland County, OH","suppressed":false,"reason":null,"verified_in_joy":false,"source":{"key":"census_acs","name":"Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-year","url":"https://api.census.gov/data","licence":"public domain","citation":"U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-Year Estimates"},"source_url":"https://api.census.gov/data/2024/acs/acs5?get=NAME,B12501_005E,B12501_005M,B12501_010E,B12501_010M,B12001_001E,B12001_001M\u0026for=county:*"},{"key":"cohabiting_households_share","label":"Cohabiting households","value":8.86,"unit":"% of households that are cohabiting couples","percentile":13.8,"trend":-34.4,"period":"2020-2024","geo_type":"county","geo_label":"Richland County, OH","suppressed":false,"reason":null,"verified_in_joy":false,"source":{"key":"census_acs","name":"Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-year","url":"https://api.census.gov/data","licence":"public domain","citation":"U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-Year Estimates"},"source_url":"https://api.census.gov/data/2024/acs/acs5?get=NAME,B12501_005E,B12501_005M,B12501_010E,B12501_010M,B12001_001E,B12001_001M\u0026for=county:*"},{"key":"divorces_last_year_per_1k_married","label":"Divorces","value":13.9,"unit":"divorced in the last 12 months per 1,000 married people","percentile":54.8,"trend":0.0,"period":"2020-2024","geo_type":"state","geo_label":"Ohio","suppressed":false,"reason":null,"verified_in_joy":false,"source":{"key":"census_acs","name":"Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-year","url":"https://api.census.gov/data","licence":"public domain","citation":"U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-Year Estimates"},"source_url":"https://api.census.gov/data/2024/acs/acs5?get=NAME,B12501_005E,B12501_005M,B12501_010E,B12501_010M,B12001_001E,B12001_001M\u0026for=state:*"},{"key":"marriages_last_year_per_1k_unmarried","label":"Marriages","value":29.34,"unit":"married in the last 12 months per 1,000 unmarried people 15+","percentile":24.0,"trend":-5.8,"period":"2020-2024","geo_type":"state","geo_label":"Ohio","suppressed":false,"reason":null,"verified_in_joy":false,"source":{"key":"census_acs","name":"Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-year","url":"https://api.census.gov/data","licence":"public domain","citation":"U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-Year Estimates"},"source_url":"https://api.census.gov/data/2024/acs/acs5?get=NAME,B12501_005E,B12501_005M,B12501_010E,B12501_010M,B12001_001E,B12001_001M\u0026for=state:*"},{"key":"nonmarital_births_share","label":"Births to unmarried mothers","value":null,"unit":"% of births","percentile":null,"trend":null,"period":null,"geo_type":null,"geo_label":null,"suppressed":false,"reason":"no data","verified_in_joy":false,"source":{"key":"cdc_wonder","name":"CDC WONDER","url":"https://wonder.cdc.gov","licence":"public domain (data-use restrictions; suppressed cells stay suppressed)","citation":"CDC WONDER, National Center for Health Statistics"},"source_url":null}]},{"key":"liberty","label":"Christian liberty","score":67,"percentile":79.5,"trend":-4.0,"coverage":1.0,"headline":"Better than 80% of cities, down 4 points","indicators":[{"key":"rls_score","label":"Religious Liberty in the States score","value":66.25,"unit":"% of the edition's safeguards in state law","percentile":87.0,"trend":-6.0,"period":"2026","geo_type":"state","geo_label":"Ohio","suppressed":false,"reason":null,"verified_in_joy":false,"source":{"key":"rls","name":"Religious Liberty in the States","url":"https://religiouslibertyinthestates.com","licence":"published scorecards, cite the edition","citation":"Religious Liberty in the States, Center for Religion, Culture \u0026 Democracy (First Liberty Institute)"},"source_url":"https://religiouslibertyinthestates.com/state/ohio/"},{"key":"rls_safeguards","label":"Safeguards fully in law","value":12.0,"unit":"of the edition's safeguards","percentile":91.0,"trend":null,"period":"2026","geo_type":"state","geo_label":"Ohio","suppressed":false,"reason":null,"verified_in_joy":false,"source":{"key":"rls","name":"Religious Liberty in the States","url":"https://religiouslibertyinthestates.com","licence":"published scorecards, cite the edition","citation":"Religious Liberty in the States, Center for Religion, Culture \u0026 Democracy (First Liberty Institute)"},"source_url":"https://religiouslibertyinthestates.com/safeguard/absentee-voting/"},{"key":"state_rfra","label":"State Religious Freedom Restoration Act","value":0.0,"unit":"1 = full protection, 0 = none","percentile":20.0,"trend":null,"period":"2026","geo_type":"state","geo_label":"Ohio","suppressed":false,"reason":null,"verified_in_joy":false,"source":{"key":"rls","name":"Religious Liberty in the States","url":"https://religiouslibertyinthestates.com","licence":"published scorecards, cite the edition","citation":"Religious Liberty in the States, Center for Religion, Culture \u0026 Democracy (First Liberty Institute)"},"source_url":"https://religiouslibertyinthestates.com/safeguard/religious-freedom-restoration-act/"},{"key":"anti_christian_hate_crimes_per_100k","label":"Anti-Christian hate crimes","value":0.07,"unit":"incidents per 100,000","percentile":55.9,"trend":0.0,"period":"2025","geo_type":"state","geo_label":"Ohio","suppressed":false,"reason":null,"verified_in_joy":false,"source":{"key":"fbi_crime","name":"FBI Crime Data Explorer","url":"https://api.usa.gov/crime/fbi/cde","licence":"public domain","citation":"FBI Crime Data Explorer (reporting gaps noted)"},"source_url":"https://api.usa.gov/crime/fbi/cde/hate-crime/state/OH?from=01-2025\u0026to=12-2025"},{"key":"school_choice","label":"School choice","value":2.0,"unit":"0-2","percentile":86.3,"trend":null,"period":"2026","geo_type":"state","geo_label":"Ohio","suppressed":false,"reason":null,"verified_in_joy":false,"source":{"key":"liberty_register","name":"The Liberty register (config/conditions/liberty_laws.yml)","url":"https://joyproject.com/methodology","licence":"Joy Project, each item cited","citation":"Joy Project Liberty register"},"source_url":"https://www.edchoice.org/school-choice/school-choice-in-america/"},{"key":"life_protections","label":"Protections for the unborn","value":0.0,"unit":"0-2","percentile":29.4,"trend":null,"period":"2026","geo_type":"state","geo_label":"Ohio","suppressed":false,"reason":null,"verified_in_joy":false,"source":{"key":"liberty_register","name":"The Liberty register (config/conditions/liberty_laws.yml)","url":"https://joyproject.com/methodology","licence":"Joy Project, each item cited","citation":"Joy Project Liberty register"},"source_url":"https://states.guttmacher.org/policies/"},{"key":"homeschool_freedom","label":"Homeschool freedom","value":1.0,"unit":"0-2","percentile":31.4,"trend":null,"period":"2026","geo_type":"state","geo_label":"Ohio","suppressed":false,"reason":null,"verified_in_joy":false,"source":{"key":"liberty_register","name":"The Liberty register (config/conditions/liberty_laws.yml)","url":"https://joyproject.com/methodology","licence":"Joy Project, each item cited","citation":"Joy Project Liberty register"},"source_url":"https://hslda.org/legal"}]}],"milestones":[]}